Some
Speculations on the effect of Geomagnetism on the Pineal Gland
1.
S.M.
Roney - Dougal
Psi Research Centre,
Glastonbury, Somerset, Britain.
Gunther Vogl,
Burghauser Str., 30,
Altotting,Germany.
Abstract
Research
over the past 10 years into the pineal gland and its possible
connection with a psi-conducive state of consciousness (Roney
Dougal, 1986 & 1989), has recently become linked with research
on the connection between the earth's magnetic field (EMF) and
psi awareness (Persinger, 1988a; Roney - Dougal, 1988). This
connection is explored with particular reference to neurochemical
research into the effect of the EMF on pineal gland activity.
Basically, the pineal gland makes the hormone melatonin and
an endogenous hallucinogen (6-MeOTHBC) that possibly causes
a psi-conducive state of consciousness. It also has enzymes
which affect serotonin so as to produce a variety of possible
hallucinogens. The functioning of the pineal gland is affected
by the EMF. Thus the production of melatonin, 6-MeOTHBC and
the serotonin hallucinogens, is affected by variations in the
EMF, and this could well be related to variations in a psi-conducive
state of consciousness, resulting in ostensible psychic occurrences.
The implications from this synthesis are far-reaching, and those
concerning our understanding of dowsing and certain anomalous
phenomena are mentioned.
Introduction
Just
recently there has been considerable interest in the effect
of the earth's magnetic field (EMF) on living organisms, particularly
as a direction finder (Baker, 1980, 1981; Husing, 1960). This
interest seems to be spreading into much more esoteric fields,
parapsychology being one of them. There are suggestions that
psi ability is related to changes in magnetic field strength
(e.g.Persinger, 1989). There is the suggestion that psi ability
is linked with the pineal gland (Roney Dougal, 1989) - and the
pineal gland is affected by geomagnetic variations as shall
be detailed in this article. There are suggestions that dowsing
ability is related to the EMF (Williamson, 1987). There are
suggestions that UFO phenomena are linked with areas of geomagnetic
anomaly (Devereux, 1982), and UFO phenomena seem to have a psi
component (Roney - Dougal, 1991).
Putting all these individual pieces together an intriguing picture
emerges, which suggests that the old idea of a "sixth sense"
may be just that, a sensitivity to the EMF. However, this sensitivity
is a subliminal perception, and so the psychological process
by which we become aware of this information is in many ways
similar to that by which we become aware of psi inputs (Roney
- Dougal, 1987). From a practical, subjective level therefore,
awareness of the EMF and awareness of psi information will manifest
in very similar ways. Thus map dowsing (awareness of psi impressions)
and field dowsing (awareness of electromagnetic impressions)
manifest in similar ways, the dowser obtaining information from
the swing of a pendulum or from rods, these being a sort of
biofeedback tool informing the conscious mind of subliminal
body responses. This suggests, as with my research into more
traditional subliminal perceptions, that the line between sense
perceptions and psi perceptions is a very fuzzy one, the one
merging imperceptibly into the other.
1. The Pineal and Psi
There
is a large body of neurochemical and anthropological eveidence
that suggests that the pineal gland may produce a neuro-modulator
that enhances a psi-conducive state of consciousness. An abstract
of this research was presented at the PA Conference in 1985
(Roney - Dougal, 1986). For full details of this research please
see Roney-Dougal (1989, 1991). Research into the neurochemistry
and related behavioural effects of the pineal gland is very
recent and so there is no clarity as yet into exactly what is
going on, but there are some very suggestive findings emerging
from the neurochemical literature that tie in with the apparent
relationship between psi expriences and changes in magnetic
field intensity.
In brief, the pineal gland has been found to synthesise melatonin,
various beta-carbolines and certain peptides, and to contain
enzymes that produce psychoactive compounds from serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine)
and its precursor tryptamine (Strassman, 1990). These have wide-ranging
effects throughout our brain and body, affecting sexuality,
adrenals, pancreas, thyroids, and other emotional and endocrine
activities. The pineal works together with the pituitary through
the hypothalamus controlling the endocrine system. Basically
it governs our circadian rhythm, is implicated in our emotional
state, reproductive function, possibly dream sleep and in certain
psychoses.
Of most interest here is the pineal gland as the psychic centre.
It has been found to produce neuromodulators called beta-carbolines
which are MAO inhibitors that prevent the breakdown of serotonin.
This results in an accumulation of physiologically active amines
within the neuronal synapses which may lead to hallucinations.
Further there is the possiblity that another hallucinogen 5-methoxy
dimethyltryptamine is synthesised in the pineal from serotonin
(Strassman, 1990). The pineal contains the greatest concentration
of serotonin in the brain, this being accentuated in those who
suffer from psychoses. Because beta-carbolines are MAO inhibitors
they may also act by increasing the levels of these endogenous
tryptamines (Strassman, 1990). The pineal also contains enzymes
that inhibit synthesis of these hallucinogenic compounds, thus
suggesting a regulating mechanism within this gland. There is
a suggestion that it is the action of the pineal beta-carbolines
on serotonin that triggers dreaming (Callaway, 1988) and it
is often reported in parapsychology that most spontaneous psi
experiences occur during the sleeping and dreaming state of
consciousness. Further, there is now a considerable body of
research into the action of serotonin and melatonin in relation
to psychiatric disorders such as manic-depression (Halaris,
1987) and schizophrenia (Bigelow, 1974, Tanimukai et al., 1970).
Anthropological data suggest that these beta-carbolines, in
particular 6MeOTHBC (6-Methoxytetrahydrobetacarboline), are
psi-conducive because their chemical structure is very similar
to a naturally occuring group of chemicals called harmala alkaloids
which occur in an Amazonian vine, Banisteriopsis caapi, used
by Amazonian tribes for specifically psychic purposes (Roney
- Dougal, 1986 & 1989). This vine is used extensively over
a wide area of South America for healing, out-of-body experiences,
clairvoyance and precognition. It is only used when psi experiences
are desired. My speculation is that when the pineal gland is
stimulated to produce these chemicals we are more likely to
enter an altered state of consciousness which is psi-conducive.
2. Geomagnetism and Psychic Ability
There
has been continuous lore concerning magnetism and mental effects,
the first well known example being that of Mesmer, even though
he was discredited. Various mediums, such as Bertha Harris,
have reported sensitivity to the EMF, but the only research
I have found with regard to mediums and electromagnetic field
effects is that in which Eileen Garrett sat in a Faraday chamber
which was either electrically charged or left in its ground
state to see how this would affect her. It was found that when
charged she obtained statistically significant scoring (Puharich,
1962).
Recent research (Adams, 1986; Persinger, 1986) has found that:
a) remote-viewing experiments are more successful when the (daily
average aa values of the) geomagnetic field is relatively quiet;
b) taking selected criterion cases from Stevenson, Phantasms
of the Living, and Fate, that spontaneous telepathic impressions
were more frequent on days of quiet geomagnetic activity;
c) this relationship did not hold for precognition; and
d) that poltergeist episodes are correlated with sudden increases
in geomagnetic activity (Gearhart & Persinger, 1986).
Since then there have been numerous reports in the literature,
of which a selection follow.
Persinger (1988a) analysed the Maimonides Dream experiments
and found that the best hits occurred when geomagnetic activity
was quiet. A single subject was tested over a four month period
and it was found that the lower the geomagnetic activity the
stronger the psi hitting. This correlation did not hold with
Honorton's Ganzfeld data nor with the Princeton data (ibid).
Persinger & Schaut (1988) found that telepathic occurrences
occurred on days when geomagnetic activity was less than when
precognitive or postmortem psi occurred, and lower than average
monthly or annual geomagnetic activity.
Tart (1988) did two psi studies which he analysed for possible
correlation with geomagnetic effects. Again, lower values of
GMF activity on days preceding more successful psi performance
was found, though not at a statistically significant level.
One of the studies showed more successful psi on days of quiet
geomagnetic activity, but not the other.
And once again we have a report of another type of psi experience
(bereavement hallucinations) which occurs when geomagnetic activity
is increased (Persinger, 1988b). Peak displays of spontaneous
experiences concerning death and crisis to significant others
occurred between 2 and 4a.m. with a secondary peak at 9 - 11p.m.
(from Gurney, Myers and Podmore collection, Sidgwick collection
& Fate collection). The hours after midnight are the time
when the pineal gland's melatonin production is at a maximum.
Following the idea that different types of psi relate to different
intensities of EMF, Braud (1989) examined four sets of his biological
psychokinesis data: spontaneous electrodermal activity, mental
influence on electrodermal activity, rate of haemolysis of blood
cells in vitro and mental influence on haemolysis rate. He found
that the relations were statistically significant for all the
measures except the in vitro haemolysis rate, such that greater
effects were shown on days when the EMF was increased. With
regard to my pineal hypothesis this finding is of added significance
because the pineal is ennervated by the autonomic nervous system,
which is being measured in all studies on electrodermal activity.
Chauvin & Varjean (1990) used an artificial magnetic field
to try and enhance PK effects, following the lead from Harvalik's
(1978) work with dowsers. They attempted to influence the fall
of lead balls in a mechanical cascade surrounded by a magnetic
field and found that when the electrical plates were at a certain
distance that a significant enhancement of influence was obtained.
This work is very preliminary but does fit in with the overall
pattern of an increase in magnetic field strength being linked
to enhanced PK.
Persinger (1988a) considers that these correlations hold over
decades as well as diurnal time spans, there being some decades
that have a noticeably quieter geomagnetic activity than others,
e.g. 1870 1879 and 1890 - 1909. He says "Perhaps this might
explain the historical episodes of psi epidemics."!
This research has been criticised by Hubbard & May (1987)
who urge that local geomagnetic measurements are made. This
recommendation is a valid one, and most of the research on the
pineal gland reported below uses local measurements or artificial
magnetic fields. It has also been criticised by Gauld &
Wilkinson (1989,1990) who analysed spontaneous case collections,
including those used by Persinger, and did not find the above
correlations.
The major basic suggestion from this body of data is that psi
ability is affected by the EMF so that when the magnetic field
is different from normal psi experiences occur.
This suggests to me that sensitivity to psi experiences is in
some way affected by the EMF. We know that certain practices
enhance psi experiences, e.g. being hypnotized, and it seems
as if a magnetic field that is different from normal may be
a similarly psi-conducive situation.
If this is so, then we must seek a physiological explanation
for this link between sensitivity to psi and geophysical variation.
I have noticed in my literature survey of research on the pineal
gland that it too is responsive to the EMF. The production of
melatonin and the possibly psi-conducive beta-carbolines in
the pineal gland, is affected not only by light and stress,
but also by the EMF.
3.
The Pineal and Geomagnetism
Over
the past decade there has been some interest in the effect of
the EMF on the functioning of the pineal gland. Most of the
experiments have been performed on animals of various sorts,
and we should be wary of generalising to humans. However, the
tiny body of research that has been done with humans in no way
contradicts the animal research. What follows is a selection
of research culled from the neurochemical literature that best
illustrates the findings with regard to the effect of the EMF
on pineal activity.
a)
Semm et al (1980, 1982), Barr et al (1983) and Cremer-Bartels
et al (1983a) have shown that the EMF affected electrical activity
of pineal cells and autonomic cells, and that the activity of
the pineal enzyme Hydroxy-indole-O-Methyltransferase (HIOMT)
is strongly dependent on magnetic field changes, such that decreased
magnetic intensity and reversed horizontal component decrease
HIOMT activity. HIOMT is involved in the production of melatonin
from serotonin and possibly in the production of the hallucinogen
5-methoxy-tryptamine from serotonin (Prozialeck et al,1978).
A lot of experiments not only change the intensity of the magnetic
field but also the horizontal component, and this too produces
changes in the activity of pineal enzymes (Olcese, Reuss &
Semm, 1988).
b) Welker et al (1983) found that artificial magnetic fields,
differing only slightly in strength from the EMF, inhibited
the melatonin biosynthesis in rat pineals at night by inhibiting
NAT (serotonin N-acetyl-transferase) activity. It seems as if
the change in MF is the important factor, because
animals habituate to artificial fields. (NAT is one of the enzymes
involved in the synthesis of melatonin from serotonin).
c) Cremer-Bartels et al (1983b, 1984) found that melatonin synthesis
is affected by changing magnetic field strengths and that the
retina is also affected. In particular they state that NAT increases
concomitantly with exposure to increased EMF, and decreases
with decreased EMF, whereas HIOMT decreases with both increased
and decreased magnetic field strengths. Therefore, NAT alone
is important for synchronising the pineal with the EMF and its
rhythmic activity persists for at least three days in constant
darkness, whilst HIOMT seems to be more implicated with the
alteration of consciousness with a change in magnetic field
whatever the direction. Reuss & Semm (1987) found that rotating
the magnetic field's horizontal component also resulted in decreased
NAT activity and therefore decreased melatonin production in
pigeons.
As a result of these findings Cremer-Bartels et al (1984) state
that: "The general biological role of melatonin
may be interpreted as translator of environmental conditions."
They conclude: "The determinations of the enzymes
involved in the melatonin biosynthesis clearly revealed that
50% increased or decreased EMF affects the melatonin biosynthesis
in birds in vitro and in vivo . . . the natural EMF variations
may be suggested to be the Zeitgeber of diurnal oscillations
of NAT in the pineal gland and retina".
d) There is some suggestion that magnetic field effects on the
mammalian pineal depend on retinal activation by light (Reuss
& Olcese, 1986, Olcese et al, 1988). Reuss and Olcese (1987)
report that not only pineal HIOMT but also retinal HIOMT is
affected by magnetic fields. Pineal NAT and melatonin content
in rats is inhibited by nocturnal exposure to a short-term very
intense (100 microTesla) MF when the rats are kept in red light
at nighttime. If the rats were in darkness when exposed to the
MF their enzyme level was not affected and was anyway lower
than those in red light. Though this could be an artifact of
the experimental method it is worth bearing in mind. As both
the retina and the pineal are ennervated by the autonomic nervous
system the suggestion is that it is this system which is influenced
by alterations in magnetic field strength.
e) However, Wever (1968) showed that shielding the EMF
desynchronised circadian rhythms in humans significantly,
even when light perception was not excluded. This suggests that
the magnetic component of the regulation of circadian rhythm
is just as important as light. When an animal is kept in constant
darkness it is found that its circadian rhythm carries on, but
on a 25 hour rhythm. Since the moon circles the earth once every
25 hours, it is possible that this is one aspect of the various
factors which govern our circadian rhythm. There are other studies
on humans that conflict with this, the people being kept in
constant darkness showing a variety of biorhythms. Early days
yet!
f) Reuss et al (1985) suggest that there is a magnetic window
and the body does not respond to fields whose strength is greater
than or far lower than this window, which is around earth strength,
but this seems to be true only for mammals and not for birds
where some of the experiments have used 50% increased or decreased
magnetic field strengths. And yet Reiter et al (1988) found
that rats exposed to high voltage (10, 65 & 130 kV/m exposure)
60-Hz electric fields from conception to 23 days of age exhibited
reduced peak nightime pineal melatonin content. Adult rats exposed
to electric and magnetic fields show reduced nighttime melatonin.
Thus high voltage 60 Hz fields to which we are all exposed when
near electricity pylons abolishes the nightime pineal melatonin
rhythm in rats.
Thus,
the pineal gland, and particularly its enzymes NAT and HIOMT
which are involved in the production of melatonin and serotonin
related hallucinogens, is definitely affected both by magnetic
and electric fields, such that decreased EMF results in decreased
melatonin production, and a short term intense change in magnetic
field strength in either direction inhibits melatonin production.
This could possibly underlie Persinger's apparently contradictory
results noted above in which he sometimes finds a correlation
with days of low EMF and sometimes with sudden increase in EMF.
It appears to be the change in EMF that is the important factor
affecting HIOMT so that potentially psi-conducive state of consciousness
hallucinogens are made in the brain through the pineal enzyme
HIOMT.
Since melatonin affects a wide range of endocrinal and neuronal
functions within the body, anything which affects the pineal
gland will have wide ranging effects. I hesitate to mention
specific behavioural effects of melatonin, but it is considered
to be a major component of our biological clock, and so is implicated
in such diverse effects as jet lag and depression, control of
reproduction and other aspects of sexuality, and a regulator
of stress together with the adrenals and the thyroid (see Roney
- Dougal, 1989 for a fuller discussion of this).
There are strong reasons to believe that the melatonin - serotonin
neural activities are linked with psychosis (Halaris, 1987,
Smith, 1978). Recent research has shown a clear link between
long dark nights in winter, depression and melatonin (Arendt,
1985). There is a possibility that the converse is also true;
long light days in summer, psychotic mania and serotonin. Thus
a reduction in melatonin production through the use of artificial
daylight lamps reduces levels of depression. Serotonin has been
linked not only with some aspects of psychosis but also with
the action of psychedelics, which were originally called psychotomimetic.
Although there are no clear experimental studies that correlate
certain psychotic states with increased psi, there is a considerable
amount of speculation in the literature that this is the case.
If so, then we have here a clear physiological rationale for
such a correlation. This aspect will be explored more fully
in a future paper.
Although, to my knowledge, there has been no specific research
yet on the production of beta-carbolines in the pineal in relation
to geomagnetic effects, it is highly probable that its synthesis
will be similarly affected since it is made in the pineal gland
from serotonin (Uemura et al., 1988). As it is speculated that
pineal beta-carbolines are responsible for the production of
dreams (Callaway, 1988) and that 6-MeOTHBC is a psi-conducive
neuromodulator (Roney - Dougal, 1986 & 1988) all this research
suggests that through the pineal gland we have a physiological
means by which the EMF can change our inherent sensitivity to
psi awareness.
This sensitivity of the pineal gland to the EMF links in with
two other areas of research, which I shall mention only briefly
here.
4. Dowsing and Geomagnetism
Dowsers
rod movements seem to be linked with changes in the intensity
of the EMF. For a full survey of the literature see Hansen (1982).
More recently, Williamson (1987) reports that the scientific
consensus that seems to be emerging is that dowsers search for
flowing ground water which is associated with geological features
such as faults. These geological faults are associated with
geomagnetic anomaly. For example: "Simmons, a geophysicist
at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology . . . conducted
surveys of gravity and magnetic fields around two dowsed wells
near Boston, Massachusetts. Unlike most other wells drilled
into the crystalline rock of the district, the holes yielded
large quantities of water, at least 140,000 litres per hour.
Simmons found that the dowsers had sited both holes within a
narrow magnetic anomaly only a few metres wide. The anomaly
resulted from a fracture zone that was channelling the flow
of ground water, hence the exceptionally high yields of the
wells."(ibid.).
This theory, that people can respond to changes in magnetic
field strength, also explains how dowsers may find veins of
metal ores. Like underground water, these veins are usually
associated with faults or fracture zones, and in some cases
ore minerals are themselves magnetic.
Experimental research into dowsers has been conducted for over
100 years the most notable being that of Solco Tromp, a Dutch
geologist (1968), Yves Rocard, a French physicist (1964), Sochevanov
& Matveev, Soviet geophysicists (1976) and Chadwick &
Jensen (1971) of Utah State University. All this experimental
research supports the idea that dowsing utilises a magnetic
sense.
This magnetic sense has also been extensively researched in
animals. It has been detected in robins, termites, cochafers,
slugs, beetles, crickets, grasshoppers, wasps and flies. For
example, Mather & Baker (1980) found that the woodmouse
uses magnetic cues for direction finding. And homing pigeons
magnetic direction sense has been well studied (Presti &
Pettigrew, 1980). These researchers have found that the magnetic
field affects not only direction finding but also other aspects
of behaviour. Stutz (1971) considered that the circadian rhythm
in gerbils is entrained by the daily magnetic field fluctutations.
Rudolph et al (1985) found that 60 Hz electric fields as well
as artificial magnetic fields affected rat behaviour, there
being a decrease in "emotional reactivity" after exposure.
Walker (1984) found that tuna could detect changes in magnetic
fields as small as one nanotesla ( less than one twenty-thousandth
of the Earth's field).
A comparable system in humans could easily be sensitive enough
to account for the results of dowsing experiments. A.S. Presman
(1970) found that electromagnetic fields have an effect on human
tissue, and this work has been amplified and developed in the
last two decades by numerous researchers (Becker, 1985; Smith
& Best, 1990; Shallis, 1988), the overall picture emerging
that we are affected by artificial electromagnetic fields in
a variety of ways from epilepsy, nausea and headaches, to bone
healing and other beneficial effects.
Baker (1981), in his book on human navigation, calls our ability
to sense changes in magnetic field strength and direction the
"sixth sense". He tested university students and found
that they could point out directions to a significant degree
of accuracy only when their blindfolds did not contain concealed
magnets. A student of his, Gai Murphy, extended his research
to children and appears to have found that this magnetic sense
of direction emerges at puberty (Young, 1989). In some experiments
researchers have noticed that the direction of the field appears
to have a biological effect (Becker,1969; Narayan Sanker, 1984;
Semm, 1982), this tallying with the research on the pineal gland
already reported.
This body of research suggests that field dowsing is at least
partially a physical response to variations in the EMF. Research
on a psi component to dowsing, as is evidenced by map dowsing,
has not been so conclusive, though Hansen (1982) reviews several
experiments that suggest that the dowsing rod is an excellent
biofeedback tool that tells our conscious mind of responses
to psi targets made by our body. This links with research on
responses to targets using the Galvanic Skin Response and the
plethysmograph in which researchers found that the body responded
to psi events (e.g. Dean, 1966; Braud & Schlitz, 1983).
All of this research suggests that these responses occur through
the autonomic system which once again brings us back to the
pineal gland which is an also innervated by the autonomic nervous
system.
5. Sacred Sites and geomagnetism
Research
into UFO's and ancient stone circles suggests that these also
appear to be connected with geomagnetic anomaly (Devereux, 1982).
The research mentioned here is very preliminary, but very interesting
and definitely warrants further investigation.
Devereux mentions Persinger and Lafreniere's book "Space-Time
Transients and Unusual Events" (1977) which analyses a
range of UFO and anomalous happenings. Their data sugest that
UFO phenomena tend to cluster in areas though there is the confounding
effect of population density. These areas were primarily areas
of seismic related stresses. During seismic strain, pressure
on the rock crystals produces electromagnetic fields through
a piezoelectric effect. The fields created by this process then
have physical effects such as ball lightning, will-o-the wisps,
and other UFO related light effects, and are also connected
with psychological and psychic effects such as poltergeist outbreaks
(Persinger & Lafreniere, 1977; Persinger & Cameron,
1986).
Devereux (1982) has shown that there is a strong correlation
not only between UFO sightings and areas of geomagnetic anomaly,
but also sacred sites, in Britain and France at least. Of the
286 stone circles extant in Britain today, 235 of them are found
on Pre-Armorican rock outcrops. Pre-Armorican rocks are those
that are more than 250 million years old (Pre-Cambrian through
to Carboniferous) and cover 36% of the land mass of Britain.
The chi-square test of this occurring by chance yields the figure
of = 169.35, p < 1 x 10-6. In other words, stone circles
are found on specific rock outcrops. These rocks are extensively
faulted. These geological faults are all areas of tectonic stress,
leading to piezo-electric effects and geomagnetic anomalies.
Measurements of unusual physical effectsassociated with megalithic
stones have been made using gaussmeters, which have shown anomalous
magnetic readings near the stones compared to the locality;
using geiger counters, which appear to show ionization effects
rather than straightforward excess radioactivity; using audiosonic
equipment which measured a high pitched sonic outburst from
the stones just at the moment of dawn; and infrared photography
which showed the same energy burst from the stone at the moment
of dawn. Several well-known and well-respected dowsers, for
example Bill Lewis, have also measured unusual effects (Devereux,
1982; Robins, 1985 & 1988). This field research is of a
preliminary nature and so the findings are only suggestive.
It is to be hoped that it will be followed up by further work
soon.
Comprehensive maps in Devereux's book (1982) show the relationship
between UFOs and earthquake epicentres, between UFOs and geological
faulting, between UFOs and areas with less thunderstorms than
the average, between stone circles, ley lines and UFOs and between
stone circles, ley lines and geological faulting.
Discussion
and conclusions
Persinger
(1988a) considers that there are two possible interpretations
of geomagnetic correlations: 1) EMF affects psi functioning;
2) EMF affects brain receptivity. This assumes that the psi
process is a constant - everpresent - and geomagnetic activity
affects the detection capacity of the brain for this information.
He considers that: "If we include the hippocampal and amygdaloid
model for psi experiences, then the geomagnetic activity might
affect the neural pathways that facilitate the consolidation
and declarative (conscious) access to this information. Without
the geomagnetic effect, the conscious awareness of the psi stimulus
within the brain might not be as probable." My research
into the pineal gland suggests that option 2 - EMF affects brain
receptivity - is most likely to be the corect interpretation
of the data.
Roll & Montagno (1985), Robinson (1985) and Neppe(1983)
have all suggested that the temporal lobe might be implicated
in psi awareness. Dixon (1978) considers that the limbic system
is the most probable. Both of these areas are closely connected
with the pineal glands neuro-endocrinal effects. Persinger(1988a)
notes that EMF temporal lobe seizures, and generalized motor
convulsions are most prominent between 2 and 4 a.m. with a secondary
peak at 10p.m. "These data suggest that some important
process within the temporal lobes is enhanced during the early
morning hours." Pineal melatonin is enhanced during the
night, its peak production occurring six hours afater the onset
of darkness, and this could be the "important process"
that links the temporal lobe with the psi process.
Persinger (1988a & b) also links temporal lobe activity
with melatonin - temporal lobe related disorders such as depression
can most definitely be related to melatonin since melatonin
has been shown to be implicated in winter depression (Arendt,
1985). Day light inhibits melatonin production but house lights
do not. One needs intensities of 2000 lux (Whitehouse, 1985)
to inhibit melatonin production, which is why so many people
get depressed in winter and sun lamps are being found to be
efficacious in curing it. I have noticed that some experiments
with rats have used red light as red light does not inhibit
melatonin production - in fact in one experiment it even seemed
to enhance it. This makes me wonder if the red light used in
Ganzfeld experiments is having some sort of physiological as
well as a psychological effect. Also mediumistic effects are
traditionally considered to be best in dim light. And most spontaneous
psi seems to occur at night time, especially whilst dreaming.
All of these are times when melatonin production, and possibly
beta-carboline production, are enhanced.
The information which I have presented here is merely the tip
of a vast body of information concerning our sensitivity to
electrical and magnetic effects. Although it is at present unclear
as to the exact mechanism within the brain of the pineal chemicals,
and their exact effects on our state of consciousness and behaviour,
this information could lead to a greater understanding of a
physiological process underlying certain psi-conducive states
of consciousness.
In conclusion, I am beginning to consider that the pineal gland
is in some way involved in the psi-conducive syndrome through
its production of melatonin and beta-carbolines which affect
us at physical, emotional and mental levels. Geomagnetism appears
to be one of the environmental conditions which seem to enhance
pineal activity although the details are not yet clear. I have
always wondered why the The fact that the EMF affects the functioning
of the pineal gland, suggests a neuromechanism by which our
psi ability is affected by the EMF, since the pineal gland makes
an endogenous hallucinogen (6 MeOTHBC also known as pinoline)
that is chemically similar to the active principle in a vine
used by Amazonian Indians specifically to produce a psi-conducive
state of consciousness (see Roney - Dougal, 1987 for details
of this research). Thus, psi ability which is reported to be
affected by changes in the EMF might be due to the formation
of these endogenous hallucingens. Hallucinations associated
with mental illness appear to be part of the same neurochemical
process and so the lore surrounding psychic aspects of psychosis
could well have a physiological foundation.
References
Adams,
M.H. (1986)." Variability in remote-viewing performance:
Possible relationship to the geomagnetic field", in Weiner,
D.H. and Radin, D.I. (eds.), Research in Parapsychology 1985,
Scarecrow Press, Metuchen, NJ, p.25.
Arendt,
J. (1985). "The pineal: a gland that measures time?"
New Scientist, 1466, 25 July, 36 - 38.
Baker,
R. R. (1981). Human Navigation and the Sixth Sense, Hodder &
Stoughton, London.
Barr,
F.E. et al. (1983). "Melanin: The organising molecule,"
Medical Hypotheses, 11, no.1.
Becker,
R.O. (1969) "The effects of the magnetic field on the central
nervous system," In (eds.), Biological effects of the Magnetic
Field, Plenum Press, NY.
Becker,
R.O. (1985) The Body Electric, Morrow, USA.
Braud,
W.G. & Dennis, S.P. (1989) "Geophysical variables and
behaviour: LVIII. Autonomic activity, Hemolysis, and Biological
Psychokinesis: Possible relationships with geomagnetic field
activity," Perceptual and Motor Skills, 68, 1243-1254.
Callaway,
J.C. (1988). "A proposed mechanism for the visions of dream
sleep," Medical Hypotheses, 26, 119 - 124.
Chauvin,
r. & Varjean, B. (1990) "Is it possible to strengthen
the psi effect using a very weak magnetic field," J. Soc.
Psych. Res., 56, 96 - 97.
Cremer-Bartels,
G., Krause, K & Kuchle, H.J. (1983a) "Influence of
low magnetic-field-strength variations on the retina and pineal
gland of quail and humans," Graefe's Archive Clin. Exp.
Ophthalmol., 220,248 - 252.
Cremer-Bartels,
G. et al. (1983b) "EMF and quails," Graefe's Arch.
Clin. Exp. Opthalmol., 22, 248.
Cremer-Bartels,
G. et al. (1984). "Magnetic Field of the Earth as Additional
Zeitgeber for endogenous rhythms," Naturwissenshaften,
71, 567 - 574.
Devereux,
P. (1982). Earthlights, Turnstone Press, Britain.
Dixon,
N.F. (1978). "Subliminal perception and parapsychology:
Points of contact," in Coly, L. & Shapin, B. (eds.),
Brain/Mind and Parapsychology, Parapsychology Foundation Inc.,
NY.
Friedman,
H., Becker, R.O. & Bachman, C.H. (1963). "Geomagnetic
parameters and psychiatric hospital admission," Nature
200, 626-628.
Gauld,
A.O. & Wilkinson, H.P. (1989) "Geomagnetic Variations
and Spontaneous Psi Phenomena", Paper presented at 13th
Int. Conf. of Soc. for Psychical Research, Bournemouth.
Gauld,
A.O. & Wilkinson, H. P. (1990) "Geomagnetism &
Psi: The analysis continues", Paper presented at the 14th
Int. Conf. of Soc. for Psychical Research, Bournemouth.
Halaris,
A. (ed.) (1987). Chronobiology and Psychiatric Disorders, Elsevier,
NY.
Hansen,
G.P. (1982). Dowsing: A Review of Experimental Research, J.
Soc. Psych. Res., 51, 343 - 367.
Honorton,
C. (1977). "Psi and internal attention states", in
Wolman, B.B. (ed.), Handbook of Parapsychology, Van Nostrand
Rheinhold, NY, pp.435 - 472.
Hubbard
G.S. & May, E.C. (1987). "Aspects of the measurement
and application of geomagnetic indices and extremely low frequency
electromagnetic radiation for use in parapsychology," in
Weiner, D.H. & Nelson, R.D. (eds.), Research in Parapsychology
1986, Scarecrow Press, Metuchen, NJ.
Luna,
L.E. & Amaringo, P. (1991). "Ayahuasca visions: the
Religious Iconography of a Peruvian Shaman," North Atlantic
Books, California.
Mather,
J.G. & Baker, R.R. (1980). "A demonstration of navigation
by rodents using an orientation cage," Nature, Lond., 284,
259 - 262.
Narayan
Sanker, P.V. et al. (1984) "Effects of pulsating magnetic
fields on the physiology of test animals and man," Curr.
Sci., 33 (18), 959-965.
Neppe,
V.M. (1983). "Temporal lobe symptomatology in subjective
paranormal experients," J. Amer. Soc. Psych. Res., 77,
1 - 29.
Olcese,J.
Reuss, S. & Semm, P. (1988). "Minireview: Geomagnetic
field detection in rodents," Life Sciences, 42, 605 - 613.
Olcese,
J. et al. (1988) "Responses of the mammalian retina to
experimental alteration of the ambient magnetic field,"
Brain Research, 448, 325 - 330.
Persinger,
M.A. (1986). "Intense subjective telepathic experiences
occur during days of quiet global geomagnetic activity",
in Weiner, D.H. and Radin,
D.I. (eds.), Research in Parapsychology 1985, Scarecrow Press,
Metuchen, NJ, p32.
Persinger,
M.A.(1988a). "Psi phenomena and temporal lobe activity:
the geomagnetic factor," Paper presented at the 31st. Parapsychological
Association Conf., Montreal, Canada.
Persinger,
M.A. (1988b). "Increased geomagnetic actvity and the occurrence
of bereavement hallucinations: evidence for melatonin-mediated
microseizuring in the temporal lobe?" Neuroscience Letters,
88, 271 - 274.
Persinger,
M. A. & Cameron, R.A. (1986). "Are earth faults at
fault in some poltergeist-like episodes?" J. Amer. Soc.
Psych. Res., 80, 49 - 74.
Persinger,
M.A. & Gearhart, L. (1986). "Geophysical variables
and behaviour: XXXIII. Onsets of histrorical and contemporary
poltergeist episodes occurred with sudden increases in geomagnetic
activity," Perceptual and Motor Skills, 62, 463 - 466.
Persinger,
M.A. & Lafreniere, G.F. (1977). Space - Time transients
and unusual events, Nelson - Hall, Chicago.
Persinger,
M.A. & Schaut, G.B. (1988). "Geomagnetic Factors in
subjective telepathic, precognitive, and postmortem experiences,"
J. Amer. Soc. Psych. Res., 82, 217 - 236.
Playfair,G.
Lyon & Hill, S. (1978). The Cycles of Heaven, Souvenir Press,
London.
Presti,
D. & Pettigrew, J.D. (1980) "Ferromagnetic coupling
to muscle as a basis of geomagnetic sense direction in animals,"
Nature, 285, 99 - 101.
Reiter,
R.J. et al. (1988). "Reduction of the nocturnal rise in
pineal melatonin levels in rats exposed to 60-Hz electric fields
in utero and for 23 days after birth," Life Sciences, 42,
2203 - 2206.
Reuss,
S. & Olcese, J. (1986) "Magnetic field effects on the
rat pineal gland: Role of retinal activation by light,"
Neurosci. Letters, 64, 97 - 101.
Reuss,
S., Olcese, J. & Vollrath, L. (1985). Brain Res., 333, 382
- 384.
Robins,
D. (1985). Circles of Silence," Souvenir Press, Britain.
Robins,
D. (1988). The Secret Language of Stone, Rider, Century Hutchinson,
Britain.
Robinson,
D. (1985). "Stress and Psi: A preliminary model involving
epilepsy, sexuality and shamanism," in White, R.A. &
Solfvin, J. (eds.), Research in Parapsychology 1984, Scarecrow
Press, USA.
Roll,
W. & Montagno, E. de A. (1985). "Neurophysical aspects
of psi," in White, R.A. & Solfvin, J. (eds.), Research
in Parapsychology 1984, Scarecrow Press, Metuchen, NJ, USA.
Roney
- Dougal, S.M. (1986). "Some speculations on a possible
psychic effect of harmaline," in Weiner, D.H. & Radin,
D.I. (eds.), Research in Parapsychology 1985, Scarecrow Press,
Metuchen, NJ, p.120 - 123.
Roney
- Dougal, S.M. (1987). "A comparison of subliminal and
psi perception: Exploratory and follow-up studies," J.
Amer. Soc. Psych. Res., 81, 141 - 182.
Roney
- Dougal, S.M. (1988). "The pineal gland's possible role
as a psi-conducive neuromodulator," in Proceedings of Int.
Conf. on Paranormal Res., Colorado State Univ., Colorado, USA.
Roney
- Dougal, S.M. (1989). "Recent findings relating to the
possible role of the pineal gland in affecting psychic ability,"
J. Soc. Psych. Res., 56, 313 - 328.
Roney
- Dougal, S.M. (1990) "Geomagnetism and the Pineal Gland:
Some Speculations," In Henkel, L.A. & Palmer, J. (eds.)
Research in Parapsychology 1989, Scarecrow Press, Metuchen,
NJ, USA.
Roney
- Dougal, S.M. (1991) Where Science and Magic Meet, Element
Books, Dorset, England.
Rudolph,
K. et al. (1985) "Effect of 60Hz electric fields on rodent
behaviour," Physiol. Behav., 35, 505 - 508.
Semm,
P. et al. (1981). "Electrical responses of pineal cells
to thyroid hormones and parathormone," Neuroendocrinology,
33, 212 - 217.
Semm,
P. (1982) "Neurobiological studies on the magnetic sensitivity
of the pineal gland," Funkt. Biol. Med., 1 (4), 207 - 213.
Shallis,
M. (1988). The Electric Shock Book, Souvenir Press, London.
Smith,
C.W. & Best, S. (1990) Electromagnetic Man, J. Dent &
Sons, London.
Smith,
J.A. (1978). "The pineal gland: It's possible significance
in schizophrenia," In Hemmings, G. (ed.), The Biological
Basis of Schizophrenia, MIT Press Ltd., USA.
Strassman,
R.J. (1990) "The Pineal Gland: Current Evidence for its
Role in Consciousness." In Lyttle, T. (ed.), Psychedelic
Mono-graphs and Essays. Vol. 5. PM&E Pub., Boynton Beach,
Florida.
Stutz,
A.M. (1971). "Circadian rhythm in gerbils relative to geomagnetic
variation," Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci., 188, 312 - 323.
Subrahmanyam,
S., Sanker Narayan, P.V. & Srinivasan, T.M. (1985). "Effect
of magnetic micropulsations on the biological systems - a bioenvironmental
study," Int. J. of Biometeorology, 29, 283 - 305.
Tart,
C.T. (1988). "Geomagnetic Effects on GESP: Two studies,"
J. Amer. Soc. Psych. Res., 82, 193 - 216.
Uemura,
T. et al (1988) "Isolation, structure and properties of
the beta-carboline formed from 5-hydroxytryptamine by the superoxide
anion generating system," J. Neurochem., 51, 710-717.
Walker,
M.W. (1984). "Learned magnetic field discrimination in
yellowfin tuna, Thunnus abacares," J. Comp. Physiol., A155,
673 - 679.
Welker,
H.A. et al. (1983). "Effects of an artificial magnetic
field on serotonin N-acetyltransferase activity and melatonin
content of the rat pineal gland," Exp. Brain Res., 50,
426 - 432.
Wever,
R. (1973). "Human circadian rhythms under the influence
of weak electric fields and the different aspects of these studies,"
Int. J. Biometeorol., 17, 227 - 232.
Whitehouse,
E. (1985). Personal communication.
Williamson,
T. (1987). "A sense of direction for dowsers?", New
Scientist, 19 March, vol. 1552, page 40-43.
Acknowledgements
I
would like to thank and acknowledge the help and inspiration
of David Pate who first introduced me to the subject, and to
Elizabeth Whitehouse, Jace Callaway, and Ben Brooksbank for
additional help with the neurochemistry.
Note
1. An earlier abbreviated version of this paper was presented
at the 32nd Annual convention of the Parapsychological Association,
1989 and published in their proceedings (Roney -Dougal, 1990).